Ex-Southern Health worker ‘warned bosses of safety failings’

BBC News 21 January 2016
Mike Holder
Image captionMike Holder was employed for three months by Southern Health to improve safety systems

An under-fire NHS trust that failed to investigate hundreds of deaths knew about health and safety failings four years ago, the BBC can reveal.

Mike Holder, who was employed by Southern Health NHS Foundation Trust, said record keeping was “haphazard”.

He said senior staff at the mental health trust were told safety failings could be breaking the law.

Trust chief executive Katrina Percy said: “We are constantly striving to find ways to do things better.”

‘Missed opportunities’

Mr Holder, a chartered health and safety practitioner, was employed as the interim head of health and safety at the trust in November 2011.

Katrina Percy
Image captionChief executive of Southern Health NHS Foundation Trust Katrina Percy has repeatedly apologised and promised to make improvements

He said: “They didn’t see how health and safety would apply to caring for the people in their care.

“I think their record keeping in general was very, very haphazard.

“I think there are missed opportunities and as a result of those missed opportunities, someone has lost their life.”

In his resignation letter, seen by the BBC, Mr Holder wrote “existing safety management systems are dysfunctional” when he left in February 2012.

He was asked to set out his findings in more detail and sent a 13-page report.

He claimed some incidents were not reported, which was “a criminal offence which you are obliged to address” and safeguarding incidents that were reported were “often incorrectly graded, downgraded by administrators or closed down without the completion of action plans”.

Mr Holder said: “When I looked at some incidents I found they hadn’t been reported.

“Within a couple of months it was quite apparent they didn’t have robust systems.”



Connor SparrowhawkImage copyrightSara Ryan
Image caption  Connor Sparrowhawk, who died at Oxford’s Slade House, had epilepsy and experienced seizures

An independent report in December found the trust had failed to properly investigate hundreds of deaths of patients with mental health problems and learning disabilities over a four-year period.

Connor Sparrowhawk, an 18-year-old with learning difficulties, drowned in a bath at a Southern Health building in Oxford in 2013 and the inquest into his death prompted NHS England to commission the report.

His mother Sara Ryan has described the trust’s leadership as “rotten” and called for resignations.

Watch the interview with his mother:

Media captionSara Ryan says the health and safety warning added ‘another layer of outrage’

Earlier in 2011 Ms Percy received an anonymous letter which said: “The trust is extremely under-resourced to deal with health and safety issues considering the size and complexity of the trust.”

Board meeting
Image captionThe Southern Health NHS Foundation Trust board reiterated its position earlier this month that there would be no resignations

In a response to the BBC Ms Percy said: “We are constantly striving to find ways to do things better and challenging ourselves to improve services across the whole organisation, as in any NHS Trust.

“All of the issues raised in the memorandum sent more than four years ago were looked into and addressed.

“Those issues in no way relate to the independent review of deaths of people with learning disabilities and mental health needs in contact with Southern Health at least once in the previous year.”

Southern Health is one of the country’s largest mental health trusts, covering Hampshire, Dorset, Oxfordshire and Buckinghamshire and providing services to about 45,000 people.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.