NHS in new part-time health service whistleblowing tsar row as second person appointed

Mirror  8 JUL 2016

The first person given the new role created by Jeremy Hunt dramatically quit earlier this year

Dr Henrietta Hughes
Dr Henrietta Hughes is the new part-time health tsar

Health chiefs have sparked fury and disbelief by appointing another part-time NHS whistleblowing tsar to do the country’s top £105,000-a-year job.

The first person given the new role created by Jeremy Hunt dramatically quit earlier this year – before she had even begun – after admitting she couldn’t do the job and her other NHS role.

But now senior officials have stunned whistleblowers by replacing her with yet another person who will only work part-time.

The key post was green lit by the Health Secretary a year ago to prevent another Mid Staffs scandal – where up to 1,400 patients died – by helping brave medics blow the whistle on poor patient care.

But the woman originally appointed to the role, Dame Eileen Sills, dramatically resigned in March – nine weeks after the Daily Mirror exposed how she was only going to do the job part-time.

dame eileen sillsDame Eileen Sills quit earlier this year


This week health chiefs have finally appointed her replacement.

But the Daily Mirror can disclose that the new NHS whistleblowing tsar, Dr Henrietta Hughes, will only work four days a week, will not start until October, and will keep her two NHS jobs as both a GP and GP appraiser.

The move has triggered shock and anger among whistleblowers.
Pharmacist Maha Yassaie, who was sacked after blowing the whistle over patient safety concerns, said she was “very disappointed” with the “very ineffective” appointment.

She added: “Another part-time one? That means no time to do the job properly like the previous National Guardian.”


Dame Eileen SillsDame Eileen Sills was also employed on a part-time basis
Mrs Yassaie, sacked as the chief pharmacist for Berkshire Primary Care Trust after making allegations about prescribing practices at the now defunct trust, said it appeared health officials had “not learned from the previous appointment”, adding: “This is just a tick box exercise.”

Dr Kim Holt, a former consultant paediatrician in Tottenham, North London, whose warning that understaffing and poor record-keeping posed a serious risk to patient safety was ignored, said she had “major reservations” about the “part-time” appointment.

And Dr David Drew, a former clinical director of Walsall Manor hospital, who was sacked after voicing concerns about a huge cost-cutting exercise, described the part-time appointment as “a sop to the large number of NHS staff who reported victimisation after they raised concerns of poor care, patient harm, wrongdoing etc”.

He also warned that the Office of the National Guardian was pointless anyway because it had limited powers to intervene in whistleblowing cases.

He added: “This is a bulldog with no teeth with respect to the new incumbent. I have not met a whistleblower who thinks this role has any chance of protecting staff or changing culture.”

Jeremy HuntJeremy Hunt has appointed a second part-time tsar
The creation of the National Guardian post was a key demand of Sir Robert Francis who led the Mid Staffs inquiry. He warned patients were at risk of harm because vital information about mistakes and concerns was not routinely being raised by staff.

Mr Hunt eventually confirmed last July he would act on the recommendation but then palmed off the post to health regulator the Care Quality Commission.

A Government source insisted the decision to appoint both Dame Eileen and Dr Hughes on a part-time basis had been taken by the CQC and claimed the Health Secretary could not have intervened to make it full time.

Mr Hunt described the appointment of Dr Hughes as National Guardian was “an important step in our ambition to create a more open and honest culture in the NHS”.

He added: “Dr Hughes will support staff so they can raise concerns without fear of discrimination and ensure the NHS is one of the safest healthcare systems in the world.”

Dr Hughes said: “I am very excited to be appointed as the National Guardian and recognise that supporting and protecting staff across the NHS who wish to speak up is a huge and tremendously important responsibility.”

One thought on “NHS in new part-time health service whistleblowing tsar row as second person appointed

  1. Pingback: NHS whistleblowing articles in 2016: TWO years post Francis Review with NO change | sharmilachowdhury

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.