NHS whistleblowing tsar hasn’t investigated a SINGLE case and won’t review any patient neglect claims until 2017

Mirror  13 DEC 2016  BY 

Dr Henrietta Hughes started her £105,000-a-year position as National Guardian in October

Dr Henrietta Hughes started her role as National Guardian in October


The £105,000-a-year NHS tsar for whistleblowing has not investigated a single case, a Mirror probe reveals.

Last year health chiefs announced the National Guardian’s Office would help NHS staff raise concerns about patient neglect.

It was a measure demanded by Sir Robert Francis, who led the inquiry into 1,400 deaths at Stafford Hospital.

But we have learned National Guardian Dr Henrietta Hughes will not review any claims of poor practice until next year. She started in early October.

The first tsar Dame Eileen Sills quit in March before her April start date after the Mirror revealed she would work just two days a week.

Dr Hughes insisted her cases would be decided by a “stakeholder advisory group”, which involves people with experience of whistleblowing.

Sir Robert Francis
Sir Robert Francis demanded the creation of the National Guardian role following his inquiry into the deaths of 1,400 people at Stafford Hospital (Photo: Youtube/The Point of Care Foundation)

But her office admitted this was “in development” and will not be established “until early in the New Year”.

Blasting the delays, Lib Dem health spokesman Norman Lamb MP described the project as a “damp squib”.

He added: “This astounding failure to investigate a single case, 18 months after the role was first announced, means patient safety is being put at continued risk.”

Dr Minh Alexander, who revealed suicides at a mental health trust in Cambridgeshire, added: “I remain highly sceptical that the National Guardian’s office is any more than a wasteful publicity stunt.”

Rt Hon Norman Lamb MP, Minister of State for Care and Support
Norman Lamb has panned the project as a ‘damp squib’
Stafford Hospital
The National Guardian Office was set up to prevent scandals such as that at Stafford Hospital from happening ever again (Photo: Getty)

And Professor Sir Brian Jarman, who helped expose the Stafford Hospital scandal, said: “The National Guardian seems to be progressing at glacial speed.”

In response to the Mirror’s ­investigation, Dr Hughes told us: “I am committed to creating a culture of openness within the NHS where staff are encouraged to raise concerns, so that lessons can be learned and care improved as a result.

“Since starting my role in October, my office has begun to do this already by developing a network of freedom-to-speak-up ­guardians across NHS trusts, who are there to enable staff to raise concerns about patient safety and to advise and support staff who seek to do so.”

One thought on “NHS whistleblowing tsar hasn’t investigated a SINGLE case and won’t review any patient neglect claims until 2017

  1. Pingback: NHS whistleblowing articles in 2016: TWO years post Francis Review with NO change | sharmilachowdhury

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: